Block on Trump's Asylum Ban Upheld by Supreme Court
Arthrex Inc., a medical device company, requested inter partes review of its patent for a knotless suture by the Patent Trial and Appeals Board. As many anticipated, the Board found several claims in Arthrex's patent invalid. Arthrex appealed the Board's decision, arguing that the way the APJs are appointed violates the Appointments Clause. The Federal Circuit agreed and provided a fix that could resolve the problem without upending the entire patent appeals system.
Under the current rules, the Board's Administrative Patent Judges (APJs) are appointed by the Secretary of Commerce. However, the Appointments Clause requires "principal officers" to be appointed by the President. First, the Federal Circuit reasoned that APJs are certainly officers (as opposed to employees) because they "exercise significant authority." Then, came the question of whether APJs are inferior officers, and therefore their appointment valid under the Constitution, or principal officers, which would present a constitutional problem.
Employing the three-part test from Edmond v. United States, the panel found that because no other official has the power to single-handedly review the decisions of APJs and they are subject to relatively little oversight, they are principal officers. Therefore, their appointment by the Secretary of Commerce runs contrary to the Appointments Clause.
Following Supreme Court guidance, the Federal Circuit concluded that the best way to resolve the constitutional issue was to sever the portion of the Patent Act that restricts the removal of APJs. Removing this provision, the court held, would make APJs "inferior officers," and allow the rest of the Board's structure to remain intact. The court made sure to note that the decision was limited to cases where:
This will hopefully assuage concerns of those who say a broader decision would have opened the floodgates for hundreds of patent applicants looking for a "do-over."
Meeting with a lawyer can help you understand your options and how to best protect your rights. Visit our attorney directory to find a lawyer near you who can help.
Sign into your Legal Forms and Services account to manage your estate planning documents.Sign In
Create an account allows to take advantage of these benefits: