Warning: The following includes details about rape and sexual assault. If you’re a victim of any type of sexual abuse and need help, please contact RAINN.
It’s a law intended to protect its state’s residents from scammers, bait-and-switch swindles, and inferior products. A new lawsuit is testing whether the Virginia Consumer Protection Act (VCPA) can be used to hold an institution of higher learning responsible for false advertising and deceptive practices.
An unidentified woman has filed a Jane Doe federal lawsuit against Texas Christian University (TCU), attempting to use her home state’s law to hold the school accountable for the rape she allegedly suffered while a student in 2024. Her complaint contends that while TCU had promoted its campus as a “safe place for women,” its original punishment for her attacker, which lacked suspension, expulsion, or any other meaningful sanctions, contradicted the school’s claims by administering a slap on the wrist to her attacker.
Doe’s sexual assault lawsuit is requesting a jury trial and reportedly seeking somewhere between $100 million and $250 million in damages, with support from Virginia Attorney General Jay Jones. TCU, which questions whether the VCPA applies to it as an educational entity, has filed a motion to dismiss and, if denied, to have the suit transferred to Texas. With the motion currently before a federal court in Virginia, the outcome could provide precedent for suing colleges without filing under Title IX, the federal civil rights law that prohibits sex discrimination in federally funded education programs.
When the Punishment Is Homework
History has shown it’s challenging to successfully bring a sexual assault lawsuit against a college or university, although the need to continue trying persists. Under Title IX regulations, plaintiffs must show deliberate indifference on the part of the school. Frustrated by her experience with TCU’s disciplinary process, Doe is instead attempting to blaze a new legal trail.
Doe’s suit alleges that in October 2024, a male classmate had initiated sex without her consent after she’d fallen asleep in her freshman dorm room. The next day, she got him to admit what he’d done and recorded his confession on a hidden phone. She filed a complaint with TCU’s Office of Institutional Equity, which handles all reports of sexual assault and dating violence on campus. After her alleged attacker was formally investigated and disciplinary hearings were conducted, he was deemed guilty of “sexual assault.” His punishment consisted of probation, changing dorms, watching short videos about informed consent, and writing a paper of about four pages on the importance of respecting consent, which he had to discuss in private with a TCU faculty member.
Doe appealed the decision, arguing that “nonconsensual sexual intercourse is rape” and that its punishment shouldn’t be “homework.” After the panel chose not to change their ruling, an attorney for Doe sent a letter to university leadership, which overturned the decision and suspended her attacker for two semesters. Doe, who had left the school by then, filed suit, claiming that TCU’s claims of exceptional campus safety and enforced sexual misconduct policies had deliberately provided a false sense of security.
Empty Marketing Promises?
Doe’s suit accuses TCU, a private university, of marketing itself as a safe place for women to attend, only to later give tepid penalties to what she described as her rapist. To reinforce her claim that the TCU campus is unsafe, the complaint claims that TCU recorded 564 reports of sexual assault between 2020 and 2024, with fewer than 5% receiving a formal investigation.
TCU disputes that comparison, saying the reporting figures may include duplicates and that some complainants wanted to remain anonymous or did not wish to pursue disciplinary proceedings. The school insists they have met all guidelines for reporting (and not reporting) sexual assaults under Texas law. TCU has asked the court to dismiss the lawsuit or transfer it to Texas, challenging the case’s connection to Virginia and the application of Virginia’s consumer protection law.
The case tests whether Virginia’s consumer protection law can reach an out-of-state university’s alleged misrepresentations to a prospective student. A ruling allowing the claim to proceed could give students another avenue for challenging deceptive recruitment practices