Uber Wins Arbitration Clause Case, Keeping Disputes out of Court
Amid controversies over sexual harassment, data security, and an ousted CEO, Uber scored one legal victory last week. The Second Court of Appeals for the Southern District of New York ruled that clicking Uber's "Register" button means consenting to a forced arbitration clause in its terms of service, meaning that customer disputes must be resolved in arbitration, rather than in court.
Spencer Meyer had sued the company over its "surge" pricing feature, but may not be able to get the case in front of a jury.
We know, we know -- nobody reads the terms of service when downloading, registering, or using an app. But that doesn't mean you can't be bound by those terms. As the unanimous court asserted, as long as there was "'[r]easonably conspicuous notice of the existence of contract terms and unambiguous manifestation of assent to those terms' ... we [will] find that a contract has been formed." The court also described Meyer's registration process:
Manifestation of Assent
The court in this case was clear that not all arbitration clauses are enforceable, and "an agreement to arbitrate exists where the notice of the arbitration provision was reasonably conspicuous and manifestation of assent unambiguous as a matter of law." So is a term buried behind a hyperlink almost no one will click conspicuous enough, and does clicking a button labeled "Register" (as opposed to, say, "I agree" or "I have read the terms and conditions") classify as unambiguous manifestation of assent? In this case, the court ruled, yes:
As long as the hyperlinked text was itself reasonably conspicuous -- and we conclude that it was -- a reasonably prudent smartphone user would have constructive notice of the terms. While it may be the case that many users will not bother reading the additional terms, that is the choice the user makes; the user is still on inquiry notice.
Meyer's case might not be dead yet -- Uber may have waived the arbitration clause by actively participating in the litigation. But it's a clear indication as to where New York and California law stands on terms of service agreements, and the clauses contained therein.
- Uber Wins U.S. Court Appeal to Push Price-Fixing Case to Arbitration (Reuters)
- Uber Settles Class Action Claim of Stealing Driver Tips (FindLaw's Decided)
- Uber Settles Lawsuit Over Driver Background Checks (FindLaw's Decided)
- Uber Settles Driver Lawsuit for $100M (FindLaw's Decided)
You Don’t Have To Solve This on Your Own – Get a Lawyer’s Help
Meeting with a lawyer can help you understand your options and how to best protect your rights. Visit our attorney directory to find a lawyer near you who can help.