Cease and Desist, B**ch: Omarosa v. Pettifleur Book Battle
It seems Omarosa didn't really pay attention when she was on The Apprentice.
The reality star and Apprentice alum, Omarosa Manigault sent a cease-and-desist letter to Real Housewives of Melbourne star Pettifleur Berenger. Omarosa claims that Pettifleur's book Switch the Bitch: My Formula to Being the Champion of Your Life, Not the Victim infringes on Omarosa's copyright for The Bitch Switch: Knowing How to Turn It On and Off. Omarosa claims that the titles are too similar.
Omarosa demands that Pettifleur provide a full accounting of her book sales and pull the book from store shelves immediately. If not, Omarosa will sue for $150,000 for each violation of her copyright.
All Bark and No Bite
Like a yappy frou-frou dog, Omarosa's cease-and-desist letter is all talk. It has no legal ground to stand on.
Copyright infringement protects works of authorship, but identifying words, names, and symbols, such as titles, are trademarks. You can't copyright a title, so we'll focus on trademark infringement instead.
First of all, you can't trademark the title of a single book. You just can't. Under sections 1, 2, and 45 of the Trademark Act, "the title, or a portion of a title, of a single creative work must be refused registration ... unless the title has been used on a series of creative works."
So, J.K. Rowlings' Harry Potter series title could be trademarked, but Omarosa's single book title cannot.
US vs. Australia
Maybe Omarosa doesn't know, but Melbourne, home of Pettifleur Berenger, is in Australia. So even if trademark, not copyright is the correct legal issue here, U.S. trademarks only apply in the United States. They hold no power in any other country. A U.S. trademark would not be able to stop someone in Australia from using the exact same title with impunity. To protect her trademark in Australia, Omarosa would have to apply for a trademark there.
Not Even The Same
Trademarks protect against consumers mistaking or confusing one product with another protected similarly named product. But these two titles really aren't even that similar. They both use the word "bitch," and "switch" but that's about it. Omarosa's face is the key component of her book cover. So, the likelihood that consumers would think the two books are from the same source is minuscule at best.
So Omarosa, you can send as many cease-and-desist letters as you want, but you're not going to win a single dime in court -- not with a copyright argument and not with a trademark argument.
- Real Housewives Of Melbourne's Pettifleur Berenger to be slapped with cease and desist letter (Daily Mail)
- Protect Your Trademark from Infringement (FindLaw's Learn About The Law)
- Can Kendall and Kylie Jenner Really Trademark Their Names? (FindLaw's Celebrity Justice)
- Hall and Oates v. 'Haulin' Oats': Duo Sues Granola Company (FindLaw's Celebrity Justice)
- Marshawn Lynch to Trademark 'I'm Just Here So I Won't Get Fined' (FindLaw's Tarnished Twenty)
You Don’t Have To Solve This on Your Own – Get a Lawyer’s Help
Meeting with a lawyer can help you understand your options and how to best protect your rights. Visit our attorney directory to find a lawyer near you who can help.