A vacation rental’s security camera caught a shirtless Bill Belichick. The footage went viral. Now, Jordon Hudson, who was dating the former New England Patriots coach at the time, is suing the hosts.
Hudson alleges that two Airbnb hosts, Elise McDevitt and Craig Nolan, exposed their private relationship by sharing footage and personal information. The case raises a question that reaches beyond celebrities: When does sharing a guest’s business become a legal violation?
From Private Stay to Viral Video
According to the civil complaint filed earlier this month, McDevitt texted Hudson a parking warning on the final night of her reservation and included Ring footage showing Belichick walking shirtless to and from the property. Hudson repeatedly sought confirmation that the video would be deleted.
The complaint quotes McDevitt as responding, “We will delete it from Ring, but as you know, unfortunately, videos are never totally deleted,” and later assuring Hudson that she was “not distributing the video.”
Hudson alleges the shirtless Bill Belichick video appeared on social media in November 2023 and spread to news outlets. McDevitt initially denied sharing it but acknowledged in a May 3, 2025, text that “We had sent it to a few people” while questioning whether the man shown was Belichick.
Hudson’s theory is that the hosts’ initial sharing of the footage led to their wider circulation and her eventual public identification as Belichick’s partner (not necessarily that the hosts personally posted the video online). She also alleges the hosts intentionally peered through a window during her stay, later disclosed private information, and supplied another Belichick video for the Pablo Torre Finds Out podcast.
Where Privacy Law Draws the Line
You don’t have to be naked to have a privacy claim. Massachusetts’ civil privacy law goes beyond intimate images and allows people to seek damages for certain invasions of privacy.
The law can cover both sharing private information and unreasonably prying into someone’s private space. Hudson alleges both: that the hosts shared information about her stay and relationship, and that they deliberately looked through a window.
But not every nosy act supports a lawsuit. In Polay v. McMahon, Massachusetts’ highest court explained that an invasion must be unreasonable and either substantial or serious.
That case involved neighbors who accused a man of using cameras to constantly monitor their home, including through its windows, to harass them. The court let their privacy claim move forward without deciding whether the man was liable. The details mattered: where and how the monitoring happened, how often, for how long, and why. Courts weigh those details against any legitimate reason for the intrusion.
That doesn’t make an ordinary doorbell camera illegal. Watching an entrance for security is different from deliberately peering through a guest’s window. And having a good reason to record footage doesn’t necessarily justify passing it around to friends.
Belichick’s fame could also matter. Courts consider whether sharing private information serves a legitimate public interest. But his celebrity status doesn’t settle the question, especially when Hudson’s privacy is at issue, too.
Broken Promises, Bigger Stakes
Hudson says the hosts didn’t just invade her privacy. They also broke their promises. She claims the rental agreement required them to follow Airbnb’s privacy rules and that they separately agreed, through text messages, to delete the footage and not share it.
She also argues that the privacy protections in the hosts’ agreement with Airbnb were meant to benefit guests like her, giving her the right to enforce them. But she’ll have to show that these agreements created binding promises and that she can enforce the relevant terms.
Her consumer-protection claim focuses on another alleged problem: The hosts shared private information while assuring her they hadn’t, and promising to delete the video and keep it to themselves. Hudson argues that this conduct was part of their rental business, bringing it within the reach of Massachusetts’ consumer-protection law.
Under Chapter 93A, Section 9, consumers who meet the law’s requirements can seek money damages and a court order to stop unfair or deceptive business practices. Winning a claim generally also means recovering reasonable attorney’s fees and costs, although rejecting a reasonable, timely settlement offer can limit that recovery.
The stakes can rise further if a business knowingly or willfully breaks the law, or refuses relief in bad faith after receiving a demand. Those findings can trigger double or triple damages, subject to the law’s settlement rules.
When Sharing Becomes a Crime
Something can get you sued without being a crime. That distinction matters here.
Massachusetts’ wiretap law generally bans deliberately recording conversations in secret without everyone’s permission, with some exceptions. Willfully sharing a conversation you know was illegally recorded can carry up to two years in jail, a $5,000 fine, or both. But appearing in a doorbell video isn’t enough. There would need to be an unlawfully recorded conversation. Hudson’s complaint alleges no such conversation and includes no wiretap claim.
A separate Massachusetts statute bans certain secret recordings of nude or partially nude people who reasonably expect privacy. It also covers certain recordings under or around clothing to capture intimate body parts. Knowingly sharing images illegally obtained this way without the person’s consent can also be a crime.
But here’s where the shirtless part matters: “Partially nude” has a specific legal meaning. It covers exposed genitals, buttocks, the pubic area, or specified portions of a female breast. A man’s bare chest doesn’t count. So footage of a shirtless Belichick does not, on its own, establish a violation.
None of this establishes that the hosts committed a crime. Hudson’s lawsuit asks a different question: Did they violate her privacy and break promises they owed her as a paying guest? She still has to prove her claims. For rental hosts, the distinction is worth remembering: Protecting your property and publicizing a guest’s private life are two very different things.