Texas Film Incentive Denied to 'Machete Kills' Filmmakers
A federal court this week killed claims by the Machete Kills filmmakers that a Texas film incentive program was unconstitutional and violated its right to free speech by denying them grants. The filmmakers argued that prior dismissal of their claims in a Texas court were erroneous, but they failed to convince the feds.
What Went Down
The Machete movies are directed by Robert Rodriguez, a Texan who regularly shoots in his home state. Rodriguez often works with filmmaker Quentin Tarantino and has a similarly irreverent style. His Machete movies were denied grants by the Texas Film Incentive Program twice, and Rodriguez argued that the denials were unconstitutional.
The Texas Film Commission grants filmmakers money to make the state an attractive place to shoot. But it reserves the right to deny grants to films that depict Texas history inaccurately, and it twice denied Machete's makers grants.
The production company sued the current and former directors of the Texas Film Commission -- charged with the grant program -- in Texas state court, where the claims were denied on the basis of the pleadings, meaning there was no trial. The filmmakers then sought relief in federal court, seeking funding for past and future film efforts.
The filmmakers also wanted the federal court to declare that the Incentive Program violated the First Amendment, Fourteenth Amendment, and Article I, Section 8 of the Texas Constitution both facially and as applied. They sought economic damages resulting from the unlawful denial of an Incentive Program grant.
But the federal court was not convinced by the filmmakers' claims that it was entitled to Texas funds for its films. If the state chose not to grant the filmmakers money because their depiction of Texas was displeasing, so be it.
The Court Concludes
The Court wrote, "[The Commission] did not forbid Machete from filming, producing, or releasing Machete Kills, but merely opted not to subsidize the film with Texas taxpayer funds. Accordingly, the district court did not err in dismissing this claim."
Rodriguez is famous for his low-budget movie magic and is known for actually making his films, engineering sound and visuals in his own garage. He is arguably a true independent. But he is not a starving artist anymore, rest assured.
Machete Kills reportedly grossed $15 million worldwide. And you should not be surprised if a third movie is in the making.
- Are Movie Ratings Legally Enforceable? (FindLaw's Law and Daily Life)
- Dungeons and Dragons Movie Coming After Legal Settlement (FindLaw's Celebrity Justice)
- James Holmes Guilty In Colorado Movie Theater Shooting (FindLaw Blotter)
You Don’t Have To Solve This on Your Own – Get a Lawyer’s Help
Meeting with a lawyer can help you understand your options and how to best protect your rights. Visit our attorney directory to find a lawyer near you who can help.