A federal judge has blocked authorities from searching data pulled from the cell phone of an immigration attorney that had been seized without a search warrant at an airport when he returned from an overseas trip. The attorney claimed he was targeted for the search in retaliation for videos he posts that warn immigrants of Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) activity and explain their rights under U.S. law.
On November 13, Massachusetts federal court judge Allison D. Burroughs issued an injunction stopping federal officers from searching the phone data. She concluded that immigration attorney Andrew Lattarulo was likely to succeed in his claim that searching his phone’s data would constitute government retaliation that violated his First Amendment rights.
Lawyers for the government maintained that Lattarulo was targeted as part of an investigation by Homeland Security Investigations (HSI) of his law firm for employing individuals who were not legally eligible to work in the U.S. However, Burroughs found no evidence that the government regularly searches cell phones as part of employment investigations. As a result, Lattarulo was likely to show that his phone would not have been searched but for speech that was protected under the First Amendment.
Investigation of Law Firm Hiring
Lattarulo is an immigration lawyer and part owner of the Georges Cote LLP law firm. He also has a popular Instagram account where he posts videos on the legal rights of immigrants. HSI, an investigative arm of the Department of Homeland Security, is investigating the law firm. The HSI investigation is focused on whether Georges Cote employs workers who are not authorized to work in the U.S.
Audai Cote, who is in charge of Form I-9, Employment Eligibility Verification for the firm, was served with a notice of inspection in September 2025. Cote’s practice focuses on personal injury, not immigration. After the firm provided the requested documents, the government sent Cote a notice of suspect documents and the law firm was given 10 days to verify the identity of employees listed in the notice of suspect documents.
Phone Seized While Returning from Abroad
In late September 2025, while the HSI investigation was underway, Lattarulo and Cote traveled from Boston to Aruba for a weekend. Cote returned to Boston on Sept. 27 without any issues. However, when Lattarulo returned to Boston Logan International Airport on Sept. 28, he was met by agents from U.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) and HSI as he left the plane.
The federal agents seized Lattarulo’s cell phone without a warrant and downloaded a copy of the phone’s data. They returned the phone to Lattarulo eight days later. The cell phone data is currently in an unreadable format, but the government plans to convert it into an accessible format if the court allows it. The copied data includes confidential information, including privileged communications between Lattarulo and his clients.
Lattarulo asked the court for an injunction barring the government from accessing the data from his phone because doing so would violate his rights under the First and Fourth Amendments. He also sought documentation of the chain of custody for the information contained on his phone.
Government’s Methods ‘Highly Unusual’
Judge Burroughs said it is generally settled that the First Amendment bars the government from retaliating against individuals for speaking out. She also noted that the government has provided no evidence that cell phones are routinely searched during similar employment investigations. Lattarulo offered evidence that it is rare for the government to pursue criminal charges against businesses that employ unauthorized immigrants.
“The fact that the government, after Lattarulo spoke out publicly against it, elected to adopt a highly unusual investigative method that appears designed to inflict a maximal burden on Lattarulo lends substantial support to an inference that its actions were pretextual,” Burroughs explained.
Burroughs added that under HSI policy, employers who respond within 10 days of receiving a notice of suspect documents to verify that their employees are authorized or take steps to address the employment of unauthorized workers have demonstrated reasonable care under the Immigration and Nationality Act. The cell phone seizure occurred three days after Cote received the first notice of suspect documents; therefore, the HSI was still in the early stages of presuming compliance. As a result, the seizure of Lattarulo’s phone short-circuited ordinary investigative procedures.
Additionally, Burroughs observed that Cote was not subject to a similar seizure, despite having greater access to the firm’s employment records. If the government were truly interested in seizing evidence at the first opportunity, Cote would have been a more logical target because he returned to the U.S. before Lattarulo.
Some Questions Remain
Because Lattarulo would likely succeed on his First Amendment claim, Burroughs declined to address his Fourth Amendment claim, observing that it would be better addressed later, when the record is fuller. However, she noted that the First Circuit’s ruling on border searches of electronic devices leaves an unresolved question about searches like this one.
The U.S. Court of Appeals for the First Circuit previously found in Alasaad v. Mayorkas that the Fourth Amendment’s warrant requirement has an exception for “routine” border searches. When conducting routine searches, immigration officials may search electronic devices without any suspicion of a crime, and they may perform non-routine searches without a warrant when the government has reasonable suspicion, Burroughs wrote.
“The question this case raises is: reasonable suspicion of what?” she asked. “In other words, what types of suspected criminal activities can the government use a warrantless advanced border search to investigate? The First Circuit in Alasaad stated that the exception applies to searches for “contraband” or for “evidence of contraband or a border-related crime.”
The difficulty presented in Lattarulo’s case is that the laws Georges Cote is being investigated for violating are arguably not border-related crimes, Burroughs wrote. She said there appears to be no connection between Lattarulo’s border crossing and the suspected crime that was the basis of the government’s border search.