Find a Qualified Attorney Near You
Find a Qualified Attorney Near You
Search by legal issue and/or location
Enter information in one or both fields. (Required)
How To Get a Lower Sentence in Federal Court: Downward Variances Explained
Legally Reviewed
This article has been written and reviewed for legal accuracy, clarity, and style by FindLaw’s team of legal writers and attorneys and in accordance with our editorial standards.
Fact-Checked
The last updated date refers to the last time this article was reviewed by FindLaw or one of our contributing authors. We make every effort to keep our articles updated. For information regarding a specific legal issue affecting you, please contact an attorney in your area.
Key Takeaways
A downward variance lets a federal judge reduce a sentence below the range recommended by the U.S. Sentencing Guidelines. This range depends on the offense level and the person’s criminal history, but is a starting point and not a rule. A downward variance can’t typically reduce a sentence below a separate statutory mandatory minimum, which is a sentencing floor set by law.
In this article, we’ll explain how downward variances work in the federal criminal justice system. If you’re facing federal sentencing or seeking post-conviction relief, understanding these rules can help. A federal criminal defense attorney can explain which arguments may apply to your situation and whether a sentence reduction is possible.
The Legal Foundation for a Variance
Every federal sentence in the country follows the same sentencing statute. It directs sentencing judges to impose a sentence “sufficient, but not greater than necessary” to achieve the purposes of punishment. The sentencing statute also lists the specific factors a court must consider before imposing a sentence. The following are some of these factors that the courts look into:
- The offense and the individual: The nature of the crime and the defendant’s history and personal characteristics
- The purposes of punishment: The need for the sentence to reflect the seriousness of the offense, deter future conduct, and protect the public
- The guideline range itself: The calculated range remains part of the analysis, even when a court departs from it
- Sentencing disparity: Sentencing disparity means two defendants with similar records convicted of similar crimes under similar circumstances receiving very different sentences for reasons unrelated to the facts of their cases, which judges are required to avoid
- Restitution: The need to provide restitution to victims, where applicable
Defense attorneys rely on these factors to request a downward variance. The strongest argument depends on the case details. Sometimes, a person’s background or hardships matter most. In other federal criminal cases, showing an unfair sentencing gap compared to similar defendants may be more appropriate. Sentencing courts find a sentencing gap unwarranted only if the other defendants are truly similar, with records and conduct that closely match. If not, the difference usually reflects real differences between the cases.
Not every difference in sentencing counts as an unfair gap. If a co-defendant received a lower sentence because they provided substantial assistance, had a less serious criminal record, or faced a different charge, that’s not the kind of disparity the law targets. It focuses on sentencing differences that legitimate factors cannot explain.
Using Sentencing Data to Argue for a Variance
Sentencing data can strongly support a disparity argument, but courts are selective about what counts. Wide, encompassing national averages are often not enough. Appellate courts have held that national averages are unreliable without details about the underlying sentences. Such figures can reflect only a broad grouping of sentences imposed on a broad grouping of defendants, without accounting for individual circumstances. Courts also look for data that compares offenders with the same guideline, such as the defendant’s final offense level and criminal history category. This is valued over general averages.
The U.S. Sentencing Commission offers data showing how people with the same guideline, offense level, and criminal history category have been sentenced nationwide over the past five years. If this data shows that similarly situated Black or Hispanic defendants receive longer sentences than white defendants in the same situation, the pattern is more persuasive to a court than a general comparison.
A defense attorney can include this data in a sentencing memorandum. This is a formal written document submitted to the court before the sentencing hearing. The attorney can argue that following the guideline range would create an unfair gap. This gap would exist compared to how similar defendants have actually been sentenced, either nationally or within the same circuit.
Attorneys may also use U.S. Sentencing Commission reports or local sentencing statistics to support the argument. These sources help show the court that the pattern appears in more than one case. This is where a federal criminal defense attorney can help. They can review the numbers, criminal history, and guideline calculation.
Presenting the Defendant as a Person, Not a Statistic
Data-driven arguments can be strong, but they may come across as little more than numbers when presented to judges. Defense attorneys use the sentencing memorandum to show the defendant as a person, not just a set of facts.
A strong sentencing memorandum covers more than just the facts of the crime. It explains the defendant’s background, family responsibilities, work history, community ties, and any hardships that played a role before any time served or supervised release. It may include letters from family, employers, or community members, as well as evidence of steps taken toward rehabilitation. Judges often review these documents closely before the hearing, so the attorney’s narrative helps shape how the court views the defendant.
Both arguments are important. A disparity argument gives the judge a legal reason to go below the mandatory minimum sentences set by the guidelines or to consider early release. The personal narrative gives the judge a human reason and makes the defendant’s story more real. Attorneys often use both to show why the law supports a reduction in sentence and who the court is sentencing.
Talk to a Federal Criminal Defense Attorney
The strength of a variance argument depends on the case details, such as the criminal history category, the nature of the offense, and how closely the comparison data matches the facts. A federal criminal defense attorney can review which arguments fit your case, gather and check the data, and build the sentencing memorandum needed to present the full picture to the judge.
A criminal defense attorney can also help with other sentencing strategies. Compassionate release motions require the court to find that extraordinary and compelling reasons justify the reduction. Judges may also consider whether home confinement adequately protects public safety before granting relief.
You may also be able to get a reduced sentence through a Rule 35 motion for assisting the government. A defense attorney experienced with the federal system can walk you through your options and help you achieve a better outcome.
Can I Solve This on My Own or Do I Need an Attorney?
- Complex criminal defense situations usually require a lawyer
- Defense attorneys can help protect your rights
- A lawyer can seek to reduce or eliminate criminal penalties
Get tailored advice and ask your legal questions. Many attorneys offer free consultations.
Stay Up-to-Date With How the Law Affects Your Life
Enter your email address to subscribe
Learn more about FindLaw’s newsletters, including our terms of use and privacy policy.
Did FindLaw Help You Understand This Legal Issue?
Make It a Preferred Google Search Source
Add to GoogleHelpful Links
Know Your Rights Before You Decide What’s Next
Meeting with a lawyer can help you understand your options and how to best protect your rights. Visit our attorney directory to find a lawyer near you who can help.