Skip to main content

Find a Qualified Attorney Near You

Find a Qualified Attorney Near You

Search by legal issue and/or location

Enter information in one or both fields. (Required)

LA County Judge Removed for Misconduct and Refusing to Answer for It

FindLaw Staff

Article by: FindLaw Staff

Last updated on

Judges aren’t usually the ones answering the questions. But when California’s judicial watchdog began asking about Los Angeles County Superior Court Judge Robert S. Draper’s conduct, his response became part of the problem. In November, the California Commission on Judicial Performance ordered him removed from office.

The decision traced a pattern that went beyond inappropriate remarks: Draper repeatedly resisted limits on his authority, then failed to adequately answer the agency investigating him.

Trouble on Leave

In 2022, medical leave took Draper off the bench, but not out of the court’s business. During the leave, he sent colleagues and staff a barrage of emails containing profanity, accusations of administrative incompetence, and claims that a psychiatrist had poisoned him with medication. He also kept trying to direct cases while another judge covered his courtroom. 

Then-Presiding Judge Eric Taylor complained to the commission that October. The investigation that followed eventually expanded to other conduct, with three judicial officers appointed by the California Supreme Court serving as special masters to hear the evidence.

The problems included more than combative emails. While Draper was on leave, a defendant successfully challenged his participation in a case. Judge Douglas Stern, who was covering his courtroom, granted the challenge and transferred the matter. 

Draper nevertheless directed staff to reverse that order and bring the case back, even after a supervising judge warned that doing so might be unlawful. Draper called it a legal mistake. The commission found bad faith and an abuse of judicial authority.

Crossing the Line in Court

That resistance to stepping aside surfaced again in Odom v. Los Angeles Community College District. Professor Sabrena Odom sued a colleague for sexual harassment and the district for failing to protect her. The trial produced a $10 million jury verdict in 2022 that was later overturned on appeal.

At a February 2023 posttrial hearing, Draper interrupted defense attorney Janice Brown, who is Black, with an extended discussion of skin color, interracial ancestry, Black quarterbacks, and civil rights history. None of it concerned a racial issue in the case; there wasn’t one. The commission rejected his explanation that he was encouraging settlement.

His personal reactions also began crowding into the proceedings. Draper invoked his college-shopping granddaughter, criticized the district for spending taxpayer money rather than settling, and became emotional while recalling Odom’s testimony. Taken together, the commission found, his conduct created at least the appearance that he had lost the professional distance necessary to remain impartial.

Recusal did not end his involvement. Draper returned to preside over another hearing and threatened to report Brown and another defense attorney to the State Bar. The commission found that he knowingly acted while disqualified and that the threats were retaliatory.

Nor were the concerns confined to litigants and lawyers appearing before him. Draper told Presiding Judge Samantha Jessner she was “cute when [she was] mad,” then repeated the sentiment after she objected. He also repeatedly patted the head of Phu Nguyen, a female attorney working as court counsel. The commission found both incidents demeaning and reflective of gender bias.

A Defense That Backfired

Draper had a chance to help his own cause by answering the allegations. Instead, the commission found, he repeatedly missed deadlines and failed to provide substantive responses, defending his conduct while accusing the agency of being used for revenge and coercion.

His accusations also targeted commission staff attorney Anne M. Hunter. He claimed she had misled the agency and told her not to contact him or impose more deadlines. The commission, however, found no evidence that her communications had been unprofessional. 

Draper blamed restrictions on his access to court records for hampering his response. Yet the commission found no evidence that he had sought the assistance available to obtain them. Meanwhile, he continued sending lengthy emails on other subjects.

Then, Draper attempted to show off his judicial record (which, unsurprisingly, backfired). He emailed colleagues and Hunter confidential materials from a years-old juvenile dependency case (including photographs of children under 10 naked in a bathtub). His defense was that the recipients were authorized to see the records. The commission rejected that argument.

Findings of Misconduct 

Both the disclosure and his failure to cooperate became findings of willful misconduct. Ultimately, the commission found nine instances of willful misconduct, eight instances of prejudicial misconduct, and one instance of improper action. The distinction matters: not every ethical violation requires proof of bad faith.

Willful misconduct requires unjudicial conduct committed in bad faith by a judge acting in a judicial capacity. Prejudicial misconduct concerns conduct that undermines public esteem for the judiciary, regardless of bad faith. Draper’s race-related comments fell into the latter category because the commission found insufficient evidence that he made them for a corrupt purpose.

Either category can support removal. Improper action cannot and was not a basis for removing him. The commission also dismissed allegations that were not established by clear and convincing evidence.

Why the Bench Couldn’t Wait

To be fair, there were considerations in Draper’s favor: he had no prior discipline during his 14 years on the bench, and the decision acknowledged his dedication, compassion, and significant health problems. The masters recognized that health issues affected his conduct surrounding the 2022 emails and, without medical expert testimony, found insufficient proof of bad faith for those communications.

But the commission weighed those circumstances against Draper’s lack of candor and continued inappropriate comments during the proceedings. The concern was not just what he had done, but his failure to recognize why it was wrong.

Draper had not been reelected and was already due to leave the bench in January 2027. The commission nevertheless concluded that waiting out his term was not enough: anything short of removal would undermine public confidence in the judiciary. It removed him and disqualified him from acting as a judge.

The decision ultimately turned on more than a judge’s failure to respect the limits of his office. It also turned on his unwillingness to accept accountability when those failures were brought to light.

Was this helpful?

Copied to clipboard