Reading is fundamental, and you should absolutely do it before you sign your name to any type of contract. It can be extremely difficult, expensive, or both, to escape the obligations of a legally enforceable contract unless there’s mutual assent between both parties. Once you sign on the dotted line of a valid contract, it becomes legally binding. Depending on the contract and the circumstances, the non-breaching party could seek damages, including compensation for certain additional losses caused by the breach.
Some situations allow you to escape a binding contract, such as if the other party does (or doesn’t do) something that leads to a breach of contract. Even a written contract can be declared void if it lacks required elements. Still, rather than hoping for unexpected exit from an agreement you willingly entered into that’s enforceable by law, take the time and effort to fully read and examine every contract you plan to enter into.
Whether it’s for a rental car or with a supplier for your small business, fully understanding the terms and conditions in what you’re about to sign is a necessity, not an option. Unless you’re certain you can give it the time and consideration it requires, you may want a contract law attorney to make sure you’re not about to make a big mistake. While some oral contracts are binding as well, let’s take a closer look at what a written contract is, what it requires, and how to get out of one (maybe).
What Makes a Contract Binding?
Whether it’s a multi-year deal involving hundreds of millions of dollars for a professional athlete or your new cable agreement, an enforceable contract ordinarily requires:
- An offer
- Acceptance
- Consideration (something of value exchanged)
- Legal capacity, and
- A lawful purpose
In a unilateral contract, a promise is exchanged for performance. In a bilateral contract, the parties exchange promises. This mutuality of obligation is the primary requirement for contract formation, as is a “meeting of the minds” between the parties.
As evidenced by the backlogs in our civil courts, not every promise agreed to in a contract is honored. Both parties may enter into the bargained-for exchange with good intentions, but sometimes things go awry. In other instances, the promisor may attempt to ignore their legal obligations. You may have signed a non-compete clause that’s much more onerous than you realized and are questioning the contract's legality, or are wondering if there’s a way out of a deal with a supplier that was good at the time of signing but is no longer your best option. Every contract is different, and the details matter.
Does Clicking “I Agree” Count?
A quick note on those end-user agreements most of us click “I agree” to without reading. You don’t need a pen to enter a contract. Clicking “I agree” to an app’s end-user license agreement or a website’s terms of service can bind you, even if you didn’t read them. But the company must give you reasonable notice of the terms and make clear that your action means you accept them. A buried link or an unexplained “Continue” button may not be enough.
If you want out, check the agreement’s cancellation and termination provisions. For subscriptions, look for renewal dates, cancellation deadlines, and any fees. Keep a record of your cancellation request and check your statements for further charges.
No Way Out (Or Maybe There Is?)
Not having read the contract isn’t a valid reason to terminate it. If you haven’t already, you’ll need to become exceedingly familiar with the contract you want to get out of. Opt-out and cancellation clauses may be part of the agreement. In addition to cancellation windows and “cooling-off” periods, you may be able to pay a termination fee to end the contract. The contract may also identify events that excuse performance or allow you to end the agreement. You also might discover that the contract itself isn’t legal.
Contracts are written to be binding, but the elements of a contract must be equitable and contain valid consideration for each party. If one side can prove the contract is egregiously unfair and unconscionable, a court can rule that it’s not now and never was a legal document, and thus not binding.
There are other possible ways to have a contract declared void. They’re highly situational and often viewed through a narrow scope by the court, so it's a good idea to consult a contract law attorney or a specialist in the relevant field.
Lack of Capacity To Contract
Anyone signing a contract must have the legal capacity to understand what they’re doing. Minors can often cancel contracts they enter into. A mental impairment may also make a contract voidable if it prevents the person from understanding the agreement or acting reasonably in the transaction. But claiming that you were intoxicated when you signed isn’t enough by itself to undo a contract. You generally must show that you couldn’t understand the agreement or act reasonably in the transaction, and that the other party had reason to know.
Being Under Duress
You can’t be forced to enter into a contract against your will. If you can prove that you only acquiesced because there was a gun being held to your head or you were being blackmailed, a court will likely declare the contract void.
Force Majeure
Force majeure clauses can excuse or delay performance when specified extraordinary events prevent a party from fulfilling the agreement. Some also allow termination. These often include “Acts of God,” such as severe weather, armed conflicts, or natural disasters. For example, a contract may stipulate that if a hurricane forces the cancellation of a festival in a park, the organizers aren’t required to pay the scheduled performers.
Lack of Serious Offer
Courts are likely to void a contract if its provisions are so farcical that a “reasonable person” would recognize that they weren’t legitimate. A famous example is Leonard v. Pepsico, Inc., where the courts dismissed a lawsuit insisting that Pepsi was making a legitimate offer to supply a U.S. Marine Corps Harrier jet fighter plane as a reward in one of its promotions. An apparent promise won’t form a contract if a reasonable person would recognize it as a joke rather than a serious offer.
Misrepresentation
Whether it’s lying by omission, making a false statement of fact, or covering up information, falsehoods in a contract can make it voidable. Depending on what’s involved, it could lead to criminal charges.
Mutual Agreement
A contract may outlive its usefulness for all parties, or it may have a flaw that was overlooked during drafting. If everyone who signed the contract agrees it should be terminated, the courts will generally allow it.
Undue Influence
An unfair contract may be subject to voiding if there’s been undue influence exerted by one party over the other to get it signed. This can manifest as an older adult being convinced by someone they’ve only recently met to sign over their assets. It can occur even when the person has the legal capacity to contract.
Working With an Attorney To Void a Contract
Contract law is often extremely complicated. It’s not a place for dabbling. If you have a contract you’d like to extricate yourself or your business from, it’s not the time to learn on the fly. You’ll likely get much better results by working with a contract law attorney. A lawyer can review the terms of your contract, explain what options and exits may be available, and guide you through the process of ending the agreement.