Snowboarders Cry Foul but Lose Equal Protection Lawsuit
In what has got to be this years' most finicky, hair-splitting case, the Tenth Circuit dismissed a lawsuit by a group of snowboarders who claimed equal protection violations by the U.S. Forest Service whose special-use permit excluded snowboarders but allowed skiers.
In the opinion of U.S. Judge Dee Benson, "the equal protection clause is not a general fairness law that allows anyone who feels discriminated against to bring an action in federal court."
Snowboarders vs. Skiers
The controversy began when four snowboarders and a civil rights group sued Alta Ski area and the U.S. Forest Service of violating equal protection laws by giving skiers exclusive rights of access to particular areas of mountaintop.
Jonathan Schofield, an attorney for the boarders, claimed that the ban was only ostensibly about equipment and was in fact a clothed campaign to keep a "group of undesirable people" -- snowboarders -- off of the mountain. The legal team claimed that the equipment ban was nothing more than a pretext and that there was no rational basis for the rule.
Square Peg in a Round Hole
However, the argument was not availing to the ears of the Tenth Circuit. The court was convinced by the argument of Frederick Thaler, who argued for Alta. Thaler said that the ban was about equipment, not about the people who used the equipment.
He clarified this point by suggesting a scenario: a person shows up at the resort with a snowboard and is turned away only to be accepted when he shows up later with a pair of skis. Thus, equipment is the target of the ban. In his words, the snowboarders were "trying to put a square peg in a round hole."
Snowboarding vs. Snowboarders
Lawyers for the snowboarders weren't about to go down without a fight, though. Schofield essentially tried his "oh, yeah" last ditch call and reminded the court of the signs on Alta's property: "They don't say 'no snowboarding'" he said, "They say 'no snowboarders.'"
Somebody give that man a ribbon for splitting-hairs.
- 10th Circuit Says 'So, What?' to Whistleblowing Doctor (FindLaw's Tenth Circuit Blog)
- 10th Circuit Welcomes New Chief Judge, Timothy Tymkovich (FindLaw's Tenth Circuit Blog)
- Colorado Marijuana Businesses Barred From Bankruptcy Court (FindLaw's Tenth Circuit Blog)
You Don’t Have To Solve This on Your Own – Get a Lawyer’s Help
Meeting with a lawyer can help you understand your options and how to best protect your rights. Visit our attorney directory to find a lawyer near you who can help.