Teachers' Unions and Collective Bargaining: Overview

Teachers' unions are organizations. They represent public school teachers in negotiations with school districts over employment terms. This is known as collective bargaining. While some states support collective bargaining, others limit or prohibit it. This affects teachers' rights and the negotiation process.

Most public school teachers belong to at least one union. These unions bargain on their behalf with federal, state, and local officials for better wages, benefits, and working conditions. Some larger unions, like the National Education Association (NEA), also lobby federal and state lawmakers. They lobby for pro-education policies and adequate funding. The ability to negotiate through a teachers' union is determined by state law. Some states prohibit the collective bargaining of public employees altogether.

This article provides a general overview of teachers' unions and collective bargaining.

Introduction to Collective Bargaining in Education

Collective bargaining is a key process in the education sector, particularly for teachers. Teachers, as with other public employees, do not have the constitutional right to collectively bargain. This is, instead, for the states to decide. Yet, the First Amendment does provide that people have the right to "peaceably assemble." This includes the right to join a union (if not as a vehicle for collective bargaining). Also, teachers do not have the constitutional right to go on strike. However, this right may be granted through other federal or state laws.

Collective bargaining involves negotiations. These negotiations happen between teachers' unions and school districts. They negotiate on the terms of the employment contracts. These contracts are collective bargaining agreements (CBAs). These agreements cover various aspects of employment relations. For example, the CBA might cover teacher salaries and school year schedules. It can also cover details like teacher evaluations.

The public sector covers most traditional schools. In the public sector, these negotiations are crucial for maintaining good working conditions. However, in the private sector, such as charter schools, the rules can be different.

Bargaining Units

A bargaining unit is a group of professionals. These professionals share a "community of interests," typically embodied by a union. A teacher may belong to more than one bargaining unit. Most teachers belong to the NEA, which is the largest bargaining unit in the United States. They may also belong to a state or local union. The NEA represents the interests of all public school teachers. A local union may serve as the bargaining unit for a single district.

State laws and the National Labor Relations Act (NLRA) establish certain procedures. for recognizing a formal bargaining unit. After a bargaining unit is organized, members may petition the proper labor board for certification. The labor board determines if the bargaining unit (or union) is appropriate. Then, the workers will vote to decide if the organization becomes their official bargaining unit.

The Role of Unions and Legal Framework

Teacher unions play a significant role in representing teachers' interests. They ensure that the school board and districts negotiate in good faith. In some states, collective bargaining rights are strongly protected. In others, especially right-to-work states, union representatives might be less influential. The Supreme Court has made several rulings that impact collective bargaining. These rulings also shape education law. For instance, some states have passed laws affecting teacher evaluations and layoffs. These aspects are often part of the CBA.

What Teachers' Unions Bargain For

CBAs outline the rights and responsibilities of both teachers and school districts. These agreements often include clauses about arbitration. Arbitration is a way to resolve disputes without going to court. They also detail processes for handling unfair labor practices.

Unions negotiate on behalf of their members for better compensation. They also handle grievances. They provide training and lobby federal and state lawmakers. They also work to improve the quality of education for students. This might mean reducing class sizes and improving curriculum. Unions may collectively bargain on behalf of teachers. They may do so for a variety of reasons, including (but not limited to) the following:

  • Academic freedom and curriculum
  • Wages and benefits
  • Hours, workload, and responsibilities
  • Tenure and promotion
  • Evaluation procedures
  • Grievance procedures
  • Retirement and pension benefits
  • Vacation and sick leave

The content of these agreements varies widely across states. Some states, including Georgia, South Carolina, and Texas, ban collective bargaining in the public sector completely.

Other Benefits of Union Membership

Teachers who choose not to join the union may not have to pay monthly dues, despite reaping the broader gains of the union (such as better pay, etc.), but they may lose other perks. For instance, teachers' unions provide legal protection and advice on a wide range of work-related issues. This may include representation and liability insurance to protect against lawsuits by parents. Additionally, union members often have access to a wide range of support and guidance, including curriculum guides and professional development opportunities.

As many as 23 states require non-union teachers to pay a fee to the union as a condition of employment, with the idea that their pay and benefits are directly related to union activity. These states include California, Illinois, New York, Ohio, and Pennsylvania.

Challenges and Future Directions

In recent years, challenges to collective bargaining in the education sector have arisen. Some states are considering voucher programs and expanding charter schools, which can affect traditional public school funding and teacher contracts. Furthermore, the concept of permissive subjects of bargaining, which are negotiable but not required, varies by state. This leads to a diverse landscape where teachers in different states experience different employment conditions. Employee organizations and unions must continuously adapt to these changes, advocating for teachers' rights while navigating the evolving legal and political landscape.

Getting Legal Help With Teachers' Unions and Collective Bargaining

Navigating the complexities of collective bargaining and teachers' unions can sometimes require legal assistance. This is especially true when dealing with issues like unfair labor practices, contract disputes, or understanding state-specific education laws. Teachers or school districts might seek help from education law attorneys. These legal professionals can help interpret CBAs. They can also offer representation during arbitration and assist in negotiations to ensure good faith practices are followed.

Was this helpful?

Can I Solve This on My Own or Do I Need an Attorney?

  • You generally need a lawyer's help to sue a school
  • School rules and regulations can be contested in court
  • Civil rights and discrimination issues are a large part of education law

Education legal issues can span Title IX concerns, discrimination cases, civil rights offenses, and teachers' rights. An attorney can help prevent common mistakes with your case.

Find a local attorney