Are Police Allowed to Racially Profile? A State Law Breakdown
It almost seems silly to ask whether racial profiling is allowed in policing. Obviously there are laws against racial discrimination in law enforcement, right?
As it turns out, there are still 20 states that haven't specifically outlawed racial profiling by police. And statutes can differ even in the states that have. Here's a quick look at how some states deal with racial profiling.
Reporting Racial Profiling
After revelations that an Arizona Sheriff's Department was systematically targeting Latinos and the Department of Justice's conclusion that police in Ferguson, Missouri similarly profiled black residents, people are wondering whether, and how, this kind of police profiling is allowed. As a recent NAACP report points out, while the majority of states (including Arizona and Missouri) have laws prohibiting police from racially profiling, many others do not.
The report focused on so-called "stop-and-frisk" procedures and their disproportionate use against black males. In researching this topic, the report also found:
- 20 state laws do not explicitly prohibit racial profiling;
- 30 states have some form of racial profiling laws on the books;
- 17 state laws ban the use of pretextual traffic stops;
- 16 states criminalize violations of their anti-profiling laws;
- 3 states allow individuals to seek injunctive relief to stop officers or police departments from racial
- 18 states require mandatory data collection for all stops and searches; 15 require analysis and
publication of racial profiling data;
- 18 states require the creation of commissions to review and respond to complaints of racial
- No states meet all of the NAACP criteria of an effective racial profiling law.
While you might think it would be conservative Southern states that don't ban racial profiling, it is generally the opposite. Georgia, Mississippi, and South Carolina are the only states south of the Mason-Dixon line that don't have laws against racial profiling. Generally, it's Western states like Idaho, Wyoming, and the Dakotas, along with states with a liberal reputation like Vermont and New York that have yet to ban profiling. You can see the full map, along with a chart of the applicable laws in each state in the NAACP report.
If you feel that you've been racially profiled or otherwise unfairly targeted by police, you may want to consult an experienced criminal attorney near you.
- Browse Criminal Defense Lawyers by Location (FindLaw Directory)
- Searches and Seizures: The Limitations of the Police (FindLaw)
- NYC Stop-and-Frisk Ruling Leaves City Potentially Liable (FindLaw's Second Circuit)
- Blacks 4x More Likely to Get Arrested for Pot (FindLaw's Blotter)
You Don’t Have To Solve This on Your Own – Get a Lawyer’s Help
Meeting with a lawyer can help you understand your options and how to best protect your rights. Visit our attorney directory to find a lawyer near you who can help.