A federal appeals court overturned an injunction that would have given some former NCAA athletes a fifth season of eligibility. In its November 6 ruling, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit held that the athletes had not adequately defined the relevant market in their antitrust challenge to the NCAA’s eligibility rules.
The 10th Circuit’s Reasoning
The case, Wisne v. NCAA, concerns NCAA eligibility rules and comes from the 10th Circuit, which covers Colorado, Kansas, New Mexico, Oklahoma, Utah, and Wyoming.
The panel explained that, for purposes of the Sherman Act, a labor market consists of employers that workers view as reasonably good alternatives to one another. Defining the relevant market is a key part of the antitrust analysis. The NCAA itself does not hire athletes to compete on its behalf; individual university athletic programs recruit them. The court concluded that the athletes had not shown why programs across all Division I sports should be treated as a single labor market.
The ruling is a victory for the NCAA, but its impact outside the 10th Circuit remains unclear. Former student-athletes nationwide have filed lawsuits seeking a fifth season of eligibility. Some NCAA member schools have supported those lawsuits in hopes of recruiting the athletes if their eligibility is restored.
“While we are appreciative of the Tenth Circuit’s decision, injunctions like the one entered by the district court have created chaos for the 2026-27 season,” said NCAA Chief Legal Officer Scott Bearby in a statement. “The NCAA membership’s decision about the implementation of the age-based eligibility rule was clear and unanimous. It is disappointing that a minority of schools continue to support efforts to flout rules they agreed to follow. The serial lawsuits and forum shopping by former student-athletes who repeatedly file suit in different jurisdictions in search of any judge willing to enter an injunction on a limited record is unacceptable.”
NCAA Updated Eligibility Rules
Until this year, NCAA Division I athletes generally had five years to play four seasons. In June, the NCAA changed its rules to give current athletes five seasons within a continuous five-year period. The change was intended to simplify eligibility rules involving redshirts, medical hardship waivers, and COVID-19 extensions. But it did not restore eligibility to athletes who had already exhausted their seasons under the previous rule.
A group of those athletes filed a class-action lawsuit in Colorado federal court, challenging their exclusion from the new rule. They argued that denying them a fifth season also denied them opportunities to earn money through Division I revenue sharing and name, image, and likeness (NIL) deals, which allow athletes to earn money from their personal brands.
The athletes argued that the NCAA’s refusal to apply the new rule retroactively unlawfully restrained trade, violating the Sherman Antitrust Act. A Colorado federal judge found that they were likely to succeed on that claim and granted a preliminary injunction allowing them a fifth season while the case proceeded.
Athletes Seeking Additional NIL Money
The plaintiffs enrolled in college in 2022 and competed in NCAA sports for four consecutive years, completing their fourth season at Division I schools during the 2025-26 academic year. They argued that applying the new rule retroactively would give them a fifth season of Division I eligibility. Almost all earned NIL money last year and said they expected to earn even more with another season.
The Sherman Act prohibits agreements that unreasonably restrain interstate or foreign trade. Under the “rule of reason” analysis, courts examine a restriction’s effects on competition in the relevant market. The 10th Circuit explained that this analysis requires first identifying that market.
In its 2021 decision in NCAA v. Alston, which addressed limits on education-related benefits for student-athletes, the U.S. Supreme Court rejected the NCAA’s argument that its educational mission and commitment to amateurism entitled it to special treatment under antitrust law. Separately, the NCAA adopted an interim policy allowing athletes to earn NIL money, effective July 1, 2021.
To support their request for a preliminary injunction, the plaintiffs submitted a declaration from a sports economics professor who described Division I college sports as a distinct labor market, separate from other college divisions and professional sports. The district court accepted that market definition and granted the injunction, finding that the athletes were likely to succeed on the merits.
No Single NCAA Labor Market for All Student Athletes
The 10th Circuit explained that a labor market consists of employers that workers view as reasonably good alternatives to one another. The NCAA does not hire athletes to compete on its behalf. The appeals court therefore concluded that the district court clearly erred by treating the NCAA as the relevant employer when defining the labor market.
Even if the court treated Division I universities as employers, it found that the athletes had not justified defining the market as all Division I athletics in the U.S. Not all Division I schools offer the same sports. For example, the court noted that only 265 of the 366 Division I universities field a football team. A football player seeking a Division I roster spot would not consider the 101 schools without a team reasonable alternatives to schools with one.
“In the absence of a plausible market definition, the antitrust challenge to the NCAA’s failure to apply the new rule retroactively cannot proceed to the next analytical steps of the rule of reason,” the 10th Circuit concluded. “A properly defined market is a prerequisite to the assessment of the anti-competitive effects and pro-competitive justifications of the prospective application of the new rule in that market.”
Further Appeals Possible
The plaintiffs in Wisne could ask the U.S. Supreme Court to review the 10th Circuit’s decision. Although the Supreme Court has previously rejected the NCAA’s claim to special treatment under antitrust law, that does not resolve whether the eligibility restriction challenged here violates the Sherman Act. Bearby said the NCAA would continue to defend its new eligibility rule if the case is appealed.