Skip to main content

Reasons for Eminent Domain: Public Use and Necessity

Key Takeaways

  • Eminent domain is the government’s power to take property for the general public good.
  • The law limits this regulatory taking power in several ways.
  • The government must meet requirements, including providing private owners with just compensation.
  • The government must also justify a public use requirement.

Sometimes government, such as a municipality, needs to seize property belonging to a private party. The government may need to violate property rights to do so.

Reasons for the power of eminent domain include public projects such as highways and bridges. State and federal governments make use of eminent domain for economic development. 

But when a government wants to seize property through eminent domain law, it must justify the taking’s necessity for the common good. Below is a discussion of how this gets determined and how governments may use their authority to condemn private properties.

If you have more questions or need legal representation, reach out to a local eminent domain attorney. In some cases, you may even be able to recover attorney fees if you win your eminent domain case.

When Owners Disagree With a Taking

Suppose a city wants to build an overpass to help relieve traffic congestion. Because there is traffic in its rapidly growing suburbs, the community has supported the project for years. The city has started the bidding process for contractors.

Before work can begin, there’s still a parcel of private property that needs clearing before redevelopment. But the owner of the private land doesn’t want to move. They’re challenging whether the city has given adequate justification for invoking eminent domain.

A court would probably greenlight the city’s taking of the private property for the highway overpass. The government will have to pay the property owner the fair market value of their real estate.

Definition of Public Use

In general, public use confers some benefit or advantage to the public. Freeways and other public-use infrastructure projects are common examples. However, the term doesn’t necessarily imply direct use by the public. Public use isn’t limited to direct interactions with the improvement.

Eminent domain may benefit a smaller sector of members of the public in a particular locality. Real property redevelopment may bring a public benefit to a subdivision of the general public.

In other words, it’s not necessary that the intended users be all members of the public. It’s the purpose for the taking that must be for the public, and not for the benefit of any private entities.

Definition of Necessity

In eminent domain cases, the use or purpose must be a needed one. It can’t be surrendered without obvious general loss or inconvenience.

The law doesn’t set an absolute definition of needed public use because of factors such as:

  • Changing needs of society
  • Increases in population
  • Developing modes of transportation and communications

The legal definition is flexible enough to allow the government to respond to these factors. However, the government must be able to justify its decision. 

How the Necessity of Eminent Domain Is Determined

A government entity’s legislature may determine:

But the law mandates what circumstances justify the action. Federal, state, and local governments must all follow the “Takings Clause” of the Fifth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution. The U.S. Supreme Court has said taking requires a justified “public use.”

When the government takes property, it’s not enough that it pays fair compensation for the value of the property. State laws establish processes for determining whether a planned taking is necessary in the first place. They often include public hearings and opportunities to challenge the justification.

The following is a sample of how states determine the necessity of an eminent domain case.

California 

In California, government agencies requesting the taking must adopt a formal resolution of necessity. This must be at a public hearing before proceeding with an eminent domain action. The resolution must prove that the taking is for a public project. It must be “located in such a manner as to offer the greatest public benefit with the least private detriment.”

Illinois

In Illinois, agencies requesting land through eminent domain must prove (and may submit evidence showing) that “the acquisition of the property is necessary for a public purpose.” Any party to such an action may submit evidence. Evidence includes:

  • Any benefit to the landowner
  • Any unsafe or illegal conditions of the property
  • The effect of such conditions on the property’s market value
  • The reasonable cost of improving such a property

New York

In New York, When the government wants to seize property, it must hold a public hearing at a “reasonably proximate” location to the property. The agency must publish a notice of the hearing in at least five successive issues of “an official daily newspaper” in the vicinity.

Remember that private developers are not only concerned with valuation and just compensation. If their property gets taken or limited in some way, they might want to challenge the government’s power altogether.

Government Condemnation Power

A local government may deem a property a hazard to the public. For example, it may pose a health or safety risk. Here, the government may condemn the property as unfit for human occupancy. This can happen following formal inspection and assessment.

Usually, this process begins by citation of violations involving:

During condemnation proceedings, a landowner is generally not entitled to compensation. This is true even though deprivation of property rights has happened.

Landowners may challenge the condemnation of their property. This can happen through legal processes that vary by state. State laws generally require ample notice to real property owners and allow hearings if anyone objects. Property owners may ultimately sue municipalities through inverse condemnation actions in court.

‘Excess Condemnation’ Actions

An excess condemnation action is a formal court action objecting to the taking of property. It alleges that a taking is not strictly needed for public use — or for taking more property than needed for public use.

Such “excessive” takings often stoke controversy. Governments can make extra revenue by dividing excess property into parcels and selling them at auction. This raises questions about the initial justification for the taking.

Public Use vs. Private Interests

It’s possible that a taking of property could serve the common good while also serving the interests of a private property, such as a developer. The companies that build highways and other necessary public improvements generally benefit from contracts with the local government. 

In Kelo v. City of New London (2005), the U.S. Supreme Court was called upon to determine whether the reasons for eminent domain were broad enough to include for-profit development of real estate. This development would result in needed economic growth and tax revenue for the community. In a decision that surprised many, the Court agreed.

Private interests benefitted from the plan. In explaining their ruling, the Court observed that the development plan fit within the city’s economic development plans. The Court found that because that plan serves a public purpose, the regulatory takings challenged here satisfy the Fifth Amendment.

Facing Eminent Domain? Contact an Attorney

If the government wants to seize your property through eminent domain, it must abide by the United States Constitution. It must clearly state the justification of necessity for the taking. Not all takings can be justified, but it’s up to the private property owner to object.

Learn more about eminent domain, justification of necessity, and more, by contacting an experienced eminent domain attorney.

Was this helpful?

Know Your Rights Before You Decide What’s Next

Meeting with a lawyer can help you understand your options and how to best protect your rights. Visit our attorney directory to find a lawyer near you who can help.

Or contact an attorney near you:
SPONSORED
Copied to clipboard